Recommendations
Explore Yoorrook’s 146 recommendations for systemic reform to address past and ongoing injustices experienced by First Peoples.
Yoorrook’s recommendations for immediate and lasting reform
Yoorrook for Transformation makes 100 recommendations for transformative change, urgent action and redress, including reforms relating to land, education, health, housing, economic and political life, and access to records, while Yoorrook for Justice makes 46 recommendations for reform across the criminal justice and child protection systems.
Yoorrook expects that the Victorian Government immediately commence work to implement the urgent recommendations made in this report so that they can be achieved over the next 12-24 months. Yoorrook recognises that work to fulfil these urgent recommendations may be supplemented by consultations within the treaty process. However, treaty processes must not be used as an excuse for delay where the evidence gathered by Yoorrook demonstrates a clear case for standalone reform in the immediate short term.
General recommendations
These recommendations address broad structural issues that affect many areas of life for First Peoples in Victoria.
They include reforms related to treaty, self-determination, governance, and other cross-cutting issues that underpin justice and long-term change. Together, they support a foundation for lasting transformation, informed by the truths shared with the Commission.
To ensure State accountability and give effect to First Peoples’ self-determination in relation to First Peoples-related policies and programs:
- Building on Recommendation 4 in Yoorrook for Justice and through negotiation with the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria, the Victorian Government must support the establishment of an accountability mechanism to transfer monitoring functions and full decision-making power, authority, control and resources to First Peoples for First Peoples-related policies and programs;
- For all policies, strategies, frameworks and plans related to First Peoples for which the Victorian Government is responsible, the Victorian Government must develop an easily accessible online tool showing implementation stages, funding, days outstanding and date of completion, and identify the person responsible for implementation; and
- The Victorian Government must reduce and streamline reporting requirements for Aboriginal Community Controlled Organisations and Traditional Owner bodies for service and program delivery and managing requests and notifications, including by negotiating single funding agreements with organisations.
To support the informed participation by Traditional Owners in treaty negotiations (Statewide and local), the Victorian Government must:
- Facilitate access by the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria and relevant Traditional Owner groups to annual data concerning the revenues collected by the Victorian Government in respect of:
- freehold land;
- Crown land & waterways;
- minerals and resources;
- gas and petroleum; v. forestry;
- fisheries; vii. renewables; and
- water (surface, groundwater).
- Facilitate ongoing access by the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria and relevant Traditional Owner groups to registers of third party interests in the matters described in paragraphs (a)(ii) – (viii) above including:
- interest ID number.
- enabling legislation;
- term (start/ end date);
- any rights of renewal or regrant; and
- annual royalties payable to the State.
- Empower the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria to oversee the provision and comprehensiveness of the datasets in (a) and (b) and to store any relevant data.
The Victorian Government must conduct a review of the datasets that it currently collects and publishes, as against the National Agreement on Closing the Gap Targets, and:
- Publish a copy of the review, by 30 June 2026; and
- Following consultation with relevant ACCOs and First Peoples organisations, ensure that all data sets are regularly publicly reported, by 30 June 2027.
The Victorian Government must:
- As an employer of a significant number of First Nations staff within Departments, Agencies and Statutory Authorities:
- formally recognise the cultural rights and cultural and colonial loads of First Nations staff within those settings;
- introduce a positive duty upon relevant managers (or head of the organisation) to ensure cultural safety in the case of First Nations staff;
- create new First Peoples-led oversight processes for the investigation of complaints in respect of alleged occurrences of non-compliance with this duty; and
- consider the adequacy of existing remuneration and/or leave models to recognise First Nations staff’s contributions and responsibilities.
- In the case of all other Victorian workplaces, amend the Occupational Health and Safety Act (Vic) 2004 to ensure cultural safety obligations on employers are embedded in legislation.
The Victorian Government must introduce into the employment contracts, performance and/or remuneration assessment processes for senior executives (SES-1 or above) assessment criteria regarding their performance in:
- Promoting the employment, retention and promotion of First Peoples staff;
- Directly engaging with relevant First Peoples communities, representative bodies and service provider organisations;
- Prioritising the actions within their Department/Agency necessary to support the treaty-making process; and
- Overseeing timely and fulsome implementation of recommendations within relevant reports.
Child protection system recommendations
The child protection system has caused deep and ongoing harm to First Peoples in Victoria.
Yoorrook’s recommendations in this area call for urgent reforms to prevent further injustice, ensure cultural connection and safety for Aboriginal children, and uphold the rights of First Peoples to care for their own children and families. These recommendations are grounded in truth-telling and reflect the voices and experiences of those most affected by the system.
The Victorian Government must amend the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic) to allow the Children’s Court of Victoria to extend the timeframe of a Family Reunification Order where it is in the child’s best interest to do so.
The Victorian Government must:
- recognise that the human and cultural rights of First Peoples children in permanent care to have, express, develop and maintain their culture, and to maintain contact with their Aboriginal family, kin and community, are not presently adequately respected and ensured in practice, and
- urgently work with the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria and relevant Aboriginal organisations to formulate and implement all necessary legislative, administrative and other means for respecting and ensuring those rights, including by authorising Aboriginal Community Controlled Organisations to monitor the cultural care plans of Aboriginal children who are the subject of permanent care orders.
Criminal justice system recommendations
The criminal justice system continues to disproportionately harm First Peoples in Victoria.
Yoorrook’s recommendations in this area call for transformative reform to address systemic racism, reduce over-policing and incarceration, and ensure that justice systems uphold the rights, dignity, and self-determination of Aboriginal people. These reforms reflect the truths shared with the Commission and aim to build a safer, fairer future for all.
The Victorian Government must:
- amend the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) to include a statement of recognition acknowledging:
- the right of First Peoples to self-determination
- that First Peoples have been disproportionately affected by the criminal justice system in a way that has contributed to criminalisation, disconnection, intergenerational trauma and entrenched social disadvantage
- the key role played by the criminal justice system in the dispossession and assimilation of First Peoples
- the survival, resilience and success of First Peoples in the face of the devastating impacts of colonisation, dispossession and assimilationist policies, and
- that ongoing structural inequality and systemic racism within the criminal justice system continues to cause harm to First Peoples, and is expressed through decision-making in the criminal justice system and the over-representation of First Peoples in that system
- amend the Sentencing Act to require courts to, in appropriate cases, consider alternatives to imprisonment for all offenders, with particular attention to the circumstances of Aboriginal offenders
- amend the Sentencing Act to, in relation to sentencing:
- require courts to take into account the unique systemic and background factors affecting First Peoples, and
- require the use of Gladue-style reports for this purpose, and
- ensure that:
- there is comprehensive cultural awareness training of lawyers and the judiciary to support the implementation of these requirements, and
- the design and delivery of such training must be First Peoples led and include education about the systemic factors contributing to First Peoples over-imprisonment.
The Victorian Government must amend the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic) and the Children, Youth and Families Act 2005 (Vic) to remove the requirement that the prosecution (including police) consent to diversion and replace it with a requirement that the prosecution be consulted.
The Victorian Government must:
- where appropriate decriminalise offences linked with disadvantage arising from poverty, homelessness, disability, mental ill-health and other forms of social exclusion, and
- review and then reform legislation as necessary to reclassify certain indictable offences (such as those kinds of offences) as summary offences, and for this purpose, by 29 February 2024, refer these matters to the Victorian Law Reform Commission (or similar independent review body) for urgent examination which includes consultation with the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria and relevant Aboriginal organisations.
The Victorian Government must promptly act on the review’s recommendations.
Land, Sky & waters recommendations
Connection to Country is the foundation of First Peoples’ identity, culture and wellbeing. It links First Peoples to their knowledges, lores and languages.
Yoorrook’s recommendations in this area call for urgent action to acknowledge and redress the impacts of Country being stolen from First Peoples.
Led by First Peoples, the Victorian Government must enable, support and prioritise the development of a First Peoples’ Renewable Energy Strategy for Traditional Owner groups underpinned by UNDRIP principles, which:
(a) Recognises First Peoples’ self-determination and direct interest in relation to the renewables; and
(b) Provides perpetual funding, resourcing and support for First Peoples to engage at all stages with the renewable energy sector.
Led by First Peoples, the Victorian Government must enable and support the development of a First Peoples’ Climate Justice Strategy for Traditional Owner groups underpinned by UNDRIP principles, which provides perpetual funding, for Traditional Owner groups to deliver environmental projects on their Country which will assist in mitigating, adapting and/or responding to climate change including through the Self-Determination Fund.
Working with First Peoples, the Victorian Government must conduct a review of all emergency management legislation (including the Emergency Management Act 2013 (Vic), Country Fire Authority Act 1958 (Vic), Forest Act 1958 (Vic), Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 (Vic) and their related regulations standard operating procedures, policies and other relevant documents:
- Formalise an ongoing role for Traditional Owner groups and ACCOs in incident planning, response and recovery frameworks.
- Provide Traditional Owner groups, ACCOs and ACCHOs, with secure, ongoing, self-determined funding to assist in the preparation for, response to and recovery from natural disasters (including fire, flood), emergency incidents, and health emergencies in the future.
- In the processes in (b), give weight to Traditional Owner voices regarding the protection of Country and cultural heritage.
Education recommendations
Education is the cornerstone of a just and thriving society and is often a focus of efforts to improve First Peoples’ health, safety, and wellbeing. Evidence received by Yoorrook highlights a stark disparity in educational opportunities and outcomes between First Peoples and their non-Indigenous counterparts.
Yoorrook’s recommendations on education aim to address persistent issues of racism, lack of cultural safety, inadequate curriculum materials, and limitations in workforce capability across the Victorian education system.
Guided by First Peoples, the Victorian Government must:
- Advocate to the Federal Minister for Education to direct the Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency (TEQSA) and other relevant professional bodies, to the extent necessary to mandate registered Victorian universities to include specific content about Victorian First Peoples in their courses;
- Advocate for the inclusion of the cross-curriculum priority: ‘Learning about Victorian First Peoples histories and cultures’ across all units in pre-service and post-graduate teacher courses; and
- Advocate to the relevant professional bodies for social work, medicine and nursing to stringently enforce university compliance with compulsory course requirements relating to First Peoples, and to the legal professional bodies to require compulsory First Peoples-related subjects in law degrees.
The Victorian Institute of Teaching, in conjunction with universities, must develop a qualification, such as a Graduate Diploma of First Peoples Curriculum Teaching.
Health recommendations
Colonisation and colonial systems have inflicted systemic harms on First Peoples’ health and wellbeing. These harms have compounded, resulting in the now well-described ‘gap’ in health and wellbeing outcomes between First Peoples and non-First Peoples.
Yoorrook's recommendations on health call for urgent action to address the profound health injustices First Peoples in Victoria experience.
Led by First Peoples, the Victorian Government must:
- Develop a model for an equitable proportion of funding to ACCOs delivering health services immediately.
- According to a clear published plan and timeline, transition all Victorian Government departments’ funding for ACCOs’ service delivery (where those ACCOS are delivering health services) to outcomes-focussed recurrent funding that includes indexation.
- Establish an ACCO Perpetual Infrastructure Fund to provide long-term ongoing self-determined minor capital, maintenance, planning and management resources for ACCOs delivering health services across all holistic wrap-around services.
- Prioritise pay parity, training, upskilling and leadership development of all staff in the ACCO sector in accordance with the Victorian Health Workforce Strategy and ensure that ACCOs delivering health services have a self-determining role in how this is implemented.
Housing recommendations
Appropriate housing is vital for cultural connection, actively enriching ‘spiritual wellbeing, mental health and engagement in core cultural practices’. First Peoples face housing insecurity, at rates far exceeding the general population.
Yoorrook's recommendations on housing outline the action needed to achieve a self-determined, properly supported housing system.
The Victorian Government must fully fund and implement Mana-na woorn-tyeen maar-takoort: The Victorian Aboriginal Housing and Homelessness Framework and the projects under the Framework, including in particular by:
- Addressing housing supply issues;
- Appropriately funding and supporting ACCOs to deliver housing solutions;
- Increasing support for private rental and home ownership;
- Delivering an Aboriginal-focused homelessness system;
- Fully funding and implementing the Blueprint for an Aboriginal-specific Homelessness System in Victoria; and
- Fully funding and implementing the recommendations in Aboriginal private rental access in Victoria: Excluded from the Start.
The Victorian Government must reduce First Peoples’ overrepresentation on the Victorian Housing Register by making Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander status a criterion for Priority Access to social housing.
The Victorian Government must urgently increase funding and support for Traditional Owner groups and ACCOs to provide homelessness services, transitional housing and a culturally safe housing model that meets the range of specific needs of First Peoples.
The Victorian Government must take steps to urgently increase First Peoples’ housing supply, including by:
- Making equitable and stable investments to grow and maintain ACCO community housing supply;
- Providing funding to ACCOs to implement alternative models such as build and own, managed by private agent or partnership arrangements;
- Extending the Big Housing Build and increase targets from 10% to 25% funding allocation for First Peoples’ housing over the next 5 years;
- Transferring fit-for-purpose public housing units to ACCOs and providing repair and refurbishment funding;
- Funding ACCOs to respond to barriers facing prospective First Peoples homeowners including expanding knowledge and education strategies on how to enter the home ownership market; and
- Developing new and innovative shared equity and rent-to-buy schemes for First Peoples in Victoria.
The Victorian Government must expand support for ACCOs and Traditional Owner groups to provide self-determined housing to First Peoples, including by:
- Providing feasibility and start-up costs;
- Facilitating community engagement and design of new housing projects; and
- Providing funding, resourcing and assistance to engage in and maintain registration as housing providers.
Economic prosperity recommendations
First Peoples in Victoria have been consistently excluded from opportunities to generate wealth. Colonial systems prevented First Peoples from participating in economic life and wealth creation, including through education, employment opportunities and owning property.
Yooorrook's recommendations address disparities and barriers to economic prosperity for First Peoples in Victoria.
The Victorian Government must:
- Revise the implementation timeline and proposed goals of the Yuma Yirramboi Strategy, including developing a publicly accessible monitoring and accountability plan for the strategy.
- Incentivise major corporations in Victoria’s private sector to embed more First Peoples businesses in supply chains.
- Change procurement monitoring and targets from number of contracts to total dollars spent to accurately reflect investment.
- Develop, resource and implement an Indigenous Preferred Procurement Program.
The Victorian Government must assist recruitment, development, and retention of First Peoples in the workplace by:
- Amending the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic) to include an obligation on employers and employees to take steps to ensure cultural safety and capability in Victorian workplaces.
- Creating a pipeline of First Peoples talent for identified industries with skills shortages, including bolstering access to education and vocational training for First Peoples to prepare them for high-value employment sectors.
- Monitoring and ensuring proper pay and conditions against defined targets for First Peoples in the public sector.
- Monitoring and ensuring proper remuneration for the cultural load borne by First Peoples in the workplace.
- Ensure the private sector develops recruitment, development, mentoring and retention strategies for First Peoples and support the private sector in developing such strategies
The Victorian Government must take steps to ensure increased First Peoples representation on both company and government boards through improved accountability and transparency measures, including requirements to publicly disclose board diversity and report annually on First Peoples representation.
The Victorian Government must ensure that the Self-Determination Fund is adequately resourced on a guaranteed, ongoing basis to meet its current and future purposes.
The Victorian Government must negotiate with First Peoples to establish a capital fund, through the Self-Determination Fund or other means, to enable investment by First Peoples and First Peoples organisations in capital markets and other initiatives to promote economic prosperity.
Political life recommendations
Colonial systems have long excluded First Peoples in Victoria from participating in the processes and institutions of government.
These recommendations aim to empower First Peoples to make decisions about the issues that impact them.
The Victorian Government must negotiate with First Peoples the establishment of a permanent First Peoples’ representative body with powers at all levels of political and policy decision making
Access to records recommendations
Access to records is central to uncovering and retelling the story of Victoria. For many First Peoples individuals, the release of information may also be essential to their health and wellbeing.
These recommendations address barriers to accessing, owning, and controlling records that continue to impede First Peoples’ data sovereignty rights and self-determination.
The Victorian Government must commit funding and resources to systemic reform to facilitate, embed and ensure Indigenous Data Sovereignty and Indigenous Data Governance in relation to First Peoples’ records, including through treaty by funding, resourcing and supporting the establishment of a Victorian First Peoples-controlled statewide body for First Peoples’ data, records and data governance expertise.
The Victorian Government must:
- Provide ongoing and sustainable funding for existing First Peoples-controlled archives, including for operational costs;
- Increase resources for organisations supporting First Peoples to access their records;
- Prioritise the digitisation and searchability of First Peoples’ records, including working with First Peoples to reframe how records are described; and
- Provide First Peoples with priority access to records and archives identified as relating to First Peoples.
Redress recommendations
The State providing redress to First Peoples is a critical component of truth-telling and of addressing historical and ongoing injustices.
These recommendations examine how redress for historical and ongoing injustices should be approached by the Victorian Government in its negotiations with First Peoples (including as part of the treaty process).
The Victorian Government must:
- Officially acknowledge the responsibility of its predecessors for laws, policies and practices that contributed to systemic injustices against Victorian First Peoples;
- Make official apologies to First Peoples in Victoria; and
- Negotiate with the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria a form of words for official apologies to First Peoples individuals and communities.
Through both Statewide and Traditional Owner treaties, the Victorian Government must provide redress for injustice which has occurred during and as a result of the colonial invasion and occupation of First Peoples’ territories and all consequent damage and loss, including economic and non-economic loss for genocide, crimes against humanity and denial of freedoms.
In respect of the redress obligations for the taking of land, waters and resources from First Peoples, the Victorian Government must act consistently with the principles in UNDRIP Articles 8(2)(b) and 28, including the following:
(a) Redress for economic loss including past loss, loss of opportunities and loss to future generations;
(b) Interest on economic loss;
(c) Redress for non-economic loss including cultural loss, assessed as at the date of extinguishment; and
(d) Interest on non-economic loss.
Redress should take the form of:
(e) Restitution of traditional lands, waters and natural resources ownership rights to First Peoples;
(f) Monetary compensation;
(g) Tax relief; and
(h) Such other financial or other benefits as may be requested by the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria or the local treaty bodies in treaty negotiations.
‘Redress’ does not, in principle, include equitable benefit-sharing of natural resources or the revenue or other benefits derived from the use or exploitation of natural resources. First Peoples have a separate right to equitable benefit-sharing from the exploitation or use of the natural resources on their territories. Notwithstanding this, the First Peoples Assembly of Victoria and local treaty bodies should not be prohibited from allocating additional benefit share to meet redress obligations for historical wrongs.